Federal Judge Dismisses Newsmax's Antitrust 'Shotgun Pleading' Complaint Against Fox News

Vandana Singh

September 07, 2025

Newsmax Inc. (NYSE:NMAX) on Wednesday filed a major federal antitrust lawsuit against Fox Corporation’s (NASDAQ:FOX) (NASDAQ:FOXA) and Fox News Network in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida.

On Friday, a federal judge dismissed Newsmax's antitrust lawsuit against Fox News just a day after it was filed. Newsmax filed a five-count complaint alleging violations.

The second, third, fourth, and fifth counts in the complaint, however, incorporate all preceding allegations, thus rendering the complaint an impermissible "shotgun pleading.

Also Read: 12 Stocks For 2025 NFL Season With $30 Billion Expected To Be Bet, $8 Million Super Bowl LX Ads

The suit accused Fox of engaging in an extensive and unlawful campaign to block competition in the market for right-leaning pay television news, including Newsmax.

Newsmax’s action sought damages. Under federal law, any damages awarded in this case will be trebled – meaning Fox could face significant financial liability if Newsmax prevailed.

The complaint alleged that Fox has abused its dominance in the right-leaning pay TV news market for years by coercing distributors into unfair carriage agreements designed to exclude or marginalize competitors like Newsmax.

Fox News, described in the complaint as a “must-have” channel for distributors, leverages its market power to impose restrictions that harm consumers, stifle competition, and drive up costs across the pay TV ecosystem.

Among the exclusionary tactics detailed in the complaint:

Fox conditions access to Fox News on agreements by distributors not to carry or to restrict competing right-leaning news channels.
If distributors carry Newsmax, Fox forces them to also carry low-demand channels like Fox Business or Fox Sports 2 in their most widely viewed tiers – triggering potentially tens of millions in extra fees.
These clauses penalize distributors for placing Newsmax in basic packages by requiring simultaneous promotion of Fox’s less popular channels.
Fox has allegedly pressured its guests not to appear on Newsmax, as well as run online smear campaigns and hired private investigators targeting Newsmax executives to damage the Company’s credibility.

The complaint asserted that Fox has deliberately blocked Newsmax’s growth in critical distribution platforms such as Hulu, Sling, Fubo, and other major platforms.

"Failure to comply with this Order may result in dismissal of the case without further notice," the judge wrote in the order on Friday.

The dismissal order notes that Newsmax may file an amended complaint by September 11, 2025. The amended complaint must not contain any successive counts that incorporate all prior allegations.

Price Action: NMAX stock closed at $13.31, and FOX stock closed at $55.97 on Friday.

Read Next:

As Waymo Begins Airport Testing Operations In San Jose, This User Compared The Fare Of Regular Uber Rides Vs Tesla Robotaxi

Image: Shutterstock/PJ McDonnell

Recommended

America Tapping into New "AI Energy" Starting Sept 30 at Midnight - Ad

Warren Buffett's No.1 AI Stock Not Even on Nasdaq - Ad

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too - Ad

Popular

NextEra Energy Eyes A Nuclear Revival

NextEra Energy plans to bring the Duane Arnold nuclear plant back online as major tech companies seek more nuclear energy.

Mortgage Fraud Is Now A Trump-Era Flashpoint—Here's Everything You Need To Know

Given the recent high-profile cases, Benzinga decided to take a closer look at what mortgage fraud is and how it can be committed.

Warren Buffett's Strangest AI Investment

Warren Buffett's Strangest AI Investment - Ad

He's been buying one little-known AI stock poised to boom before Sept 30.

This Chinese $30K Tesla Model 3 Rival Secured 10,000 Orders In Seven Minutes

Xpeng's P7 sedan launched in China with over 10,000 orders in 7 mins. Rival Tesla also released new models for Chinese market.

Nvidia Q2 Preview: 'Saying This Is The Most Important Stock In The World Is An Understatement' (CORRECTED)

Experts break down the key numbers and items to watch in Nvidia's second quarter earnings.

RFK Jr's FINAL Warning For American Seniors

RFK Jr's FINAL Warning For American Seniors - Ad

For years liberals have called RFK Jr a QUACK... an alarmist... and a conspiracy theorist. But now it appears he was right about a COVID lab leak... He was right about microplastics... And he was right about FDA corruption. Now, he's issued a terrifying new warning that Americans need to hear in 2025. Millions are in the crosshairs... And if you were born before Jan 1st, 1965, this affects you most of all.

New Jersey's massive American Dream mall sued for selling clothes on a Sunday

On any given Sunday, in New Jersey allows visitors to hit an indoor ski slope, surf an artificial wave, ride roller coasters — or shop for a new outfit at dozens of big-name retail stores.

Social Security whistleblower who claims DOGE mishandled Americans' sensitive data resigns from post

WASHINGTON (AP) — A Social Security official who has filed a whistleblower complaint alleging the Department of Government Efficiency officials Americans' sensitive information says he's resigning his post because of actions taken against him since making his complaint.

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum - Ad

NIL deals and social media clout are now driving merch sales into the billions. One Nasdaq disruptor is first to align with a football dynasty and a commerce giant.

Third Richest Woman In The World Eyes New York Giants Stake For Future Growth

One of the richest women in the world could have her eyes on more sports team ownership with a stake in the New York Giants.

What to know about Cracker Barrel's logo misfire and what could happen next

Like its namesake barrels that transported soda crackers until boxes replaced them, needed to change.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty.

Built for Gen Z. Backed by a Football Dynasty. - Ad

This brand's not Nike-and that's the point. It's fast, tech-driven, and built for viral drops. Now, it has equity backing from one of college sports' most iconic names.

How To Earn $500 A Month From HP Stock Ahead Of Q3 Earnings

HP offers an annual dividend yield of 4.29%, or $1.16 a year. So, how can investors capitalize and pocket a regular $500 monthly?

Sycamore Partners finishes deal to take drugstore chain Walgreens private

DEERFIELD, Ill. (AP) — The by a private equity firm is complete, ending the drugstore chain’s run as a publicly traded company.

From $3B Processed to the Next AI Boom

From $3B Processed to the Next AI Boom - Ad

This small-cap isn't hype. It's scaled. $3B+ in transactions. 1M+ live payments. Locked-in licensing revenue of $500k per year. Now it's about to roll out consumer AI agents, the real catalyst.

Super Micro Computer (SMCI) Shares Are Sliding Tuesday: What's Going On?

Super Micro Computer shares are trading lower Tuesday. The stock is caught in a downdraft affecting the broader semiconductor and high-growth technology sectors.

Jim Cramer Refuses To Chase Rally—Says 'We Sure Aren't Buying' Unless It's Discounted

Jim Cramer is sitting out the current market rally, citing excessive intervention, overbought conditions as key reasons to remain cautious.

High-Net-Worth Investors Are Shifting Funds Now - Before the Sept 15th IRS Drain

High-Net-Worth Investors Are Shifting Funds Now - Before the Sept 15th IRS Drain - Ad

Sept 15 is the IRS deadline for quarterly tax payments. While most hand over more cash, the wealthy shield capital in gold-backed accounts. The FREE Mar-A-Lago Accord reveals how to cut Q3 tax exposure, move funds into self-directed IRAs, and protect savings before the tax drain hits.

Salesforce, Rocket Lab, American Eagle, Gitlab And Figma: Why These 5 Stocks Are On Investors' Radars Today

CRM, RKLB, AEO, GTLB, FIG were among the stocks seen trending among investors on Wednesday, Sep. 3, 2025.

Trump Ends De-Minimis Exemptions To All Countries: How This Will Impact Your Online Shopping

President Donald Trump's executive order, which ends de minimis exemptions, is set to take effect on Friday. This will effectively close the duty-free shipping loophole that allowed small commercial packages worth $800 or less to enter the United States without being subject to taxes or tariffs.

Missed Chatbots? Don't Miss AI Agents

Missed Chatbots? Don't Miss AI Agents - Ad

Investors who rode C3.ai and SoundHound saw billions created overnight. The next wave? AI Agents. Acting, transacting, rewarding users, not just talking. $3B processed, 88% margins, launch in Q3 2025.

Beach on a budget: Greeks settle for day trips, priced out of iconic destinations

PORTO RAFTI, Greece (AP) — Bus coupon in hand, Diamantoula Vassiliou headed for the sea, determined to make the most of her brief beach excursion.

Microsoft (MSFT) Scored With Minecraft Movie: Is Call Of Duty The Next Box Office Hit?

Microsoft is the owner of multiple hit video game franchises, which may turn into box office hits and monetization chances for the tech giant.

America Tapping into New "AI Energy" Starting Sept 30 at Midnight

America Tapping into New "AI Energy" Starting Sept 30 at Midnight - Ad

It has enough power to fuel our economy for decades... with zero need for foreign oil. A small group of US stocks own the rights to it.

A downturn in international travel to the U.S. may last beyond summer, experts warn

LAS VEGAS (AP) — For a few hopeful weeks this summer, a bright billboard on the major highway linking Toronto to New York greeted Canadian drivers with a simple message: "Buffalo Loves Canada.”

Scott Bessent Says Trump Tariffs Delivering 'Historic Results,' GDP Growth Could Hit 5% — Justin Wolfers Hits Back: 'Ask American Manufacturers'

U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent is doubling down on the potential economic upsides of the tariffs, predicting massive revenue growth for the U.S. Government, alongside a boost to the domestic economy.

Warren Buffett's No.1 AI Stock Not Even on Nasdaq

Warren Buffett's No.1 AI Stock Not Even on Nasdaq - Ad

It's not in the Mag 7. And most people have never heard its name. Yet billionaire Warren Buffett is buying millions of shares.

Kevin O'Leary Once Revealed How Steve Jobs's Obsession With Fonts Spawned A Classroom Blockbuster And Taught Him A Key Business Lesson

Kevin O'Leary says Steve Jobs's obsession with fonts not only turned The Oregon Trail into a classroom blockbuster but also taught him a lasting business lesson about blending art, science and persuasion.

Toyota announces $792m expansion of Czech plant to build new electric car

PRAGUE (AP) — Japanese carmaker said on Wednesday it will invest 680 million euros ($792 million) on a new production line in the Czech Republic to make a .

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too

When Alabama Wins, This Nasdaq Brand Wins Too - Ad

With equity in the brand and athletes pushing viral drops, the University of Alabama is betting on more than just football wins. This company built the tech-and got the team on board.

Wall Street Gains On Rate Cut Bets, GE Hits Record Highs: What's Moving Markets Thursday?

Risk appetite returned to Wall Street on Thursday, as signs of labor market cooling in August cemented expectations that the Federal Reserve will begin cutting interest rates at its Sept. 17 meeting.

As summers grow deadlier, here's what to know about utility shutoffs

NEW YORK (AP) — As the cost of electricity outpaces inflation and summers grow deadlier, consumer advocates are sounding alarms about the risks to low-income people who can’t afford consistent air conditioning in dangerous temperatures.

Warren Buffett's Strangest AI Investment

Warren Buffett's Strangest AI Investment - Ad

He's been buying one little-known AI stock poised to boom before Sept 30.

Israel launches a satellite to expand its surveillance capability throughout Middle East

JERUSALEM (AP) — Israel has launched a new spy satellite that defense officials described as a strategic cornerstone, saying it will strengthen their surveillance capacity across the Middle East in the years ahead.

What to know about a large-scale immigration raid at a Georgia manufacturing plant

descended on a sprawling site where Hyundai manufactures electric vehicles in Georgia and detained 475 people, most of them South Korean nationals.

RFK Jr's FINAL Warning For American Seniors

RFK Jr's FINAL Warning For American Seniors - Ad

What's Going On With Boeing Stock Friday

Boeing (BA) and RAAF successfully prove MQ-28 operational effectiveness in autonomous flight trials. Program advances Australia's autonomous airpower development.

Bitcoin Retreats Despite Rate Cut Odds Spike; Ethereum, XRP, Dogecoin Also Slip: Analyst Explains Why ETH's 'Boring Phase' Is Expected to Drag On

Leading cryptocurrencies diverged from stocks on Thursday, as each market gauged the weak jobs data differently.

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum

TikTok + Touchdowns = Momentum - Ad

NIL deals and social media clout are now driving merch sales into the billions. One Nasdaq disruptor is first to align with a football dynasty and a commerce giant.

Cyberattack shuts down Nevada state offices and websites, governor's office says

LAS VEGAS (AP) — A cyberattack caused Nevada's state offices to close for two days this week and rendered some state websites and phone lines unavailable, the governor's office said Tuesday.

Trending Now